What ICE Agents Can and Cannot Legally Do During Arrests

As an immigration attorney at SG Legal Group, I often hear questions about Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the limits of their authority. News reports of plain-clothed agents using unmarked vehicles or knocking on doors early in the morning can be alarming. Many people want to know: what exactly are my rights if ICE approaches me or my family?

This article offers a clear, reader-friendly guide on what ICE agents can and cannot legally do — and the basic rights everyone should understand in these situations.

‍

ICE Authority: The Legal Framework

ICE agents enforce federal immigration laws. Their authority generally allows them to:

• Arrest noncitizens who are subject to removal (usually with a warrant).

• Conduct enforcement operations in public spaces.

• Detain individuals pending immigration proceedings.

But their power is not unlimited. The Constitution — especially the Fourth and Fifth Amendments — places important limits on what ICE can do.

‍

Public Place Arrests

In public spaces such as streets, sidewalks, and parking lots, ICE has broader powers:

• They do not always need a judicial warrant if they have probable cause.

• This is why arrests often happen outside homes or workplaces.

Your rights in public encounters:

• You have the right to remain silent.

• You can ask if you are free to leave.

• Do not present false documents or give false information.

‍

Arrests at the Home

The home is where ICE authority is most limited.

• Judicial warrants signed by a judge are required for entry without consent.

• Administrative warrants (signed only by ICE) do not authorize entry.

• You do not have to open the door. You may ask to see the warrant slipped under the door or shown through a window.

Key takeaway: If ICE does not have a judicial warrant, they cannot force their way into your home.

‍

Workplace Encounters

ICE also conducts operations in workplaces.

• For employees: you have the right to remain silent and to ask if you are free to leave.

• For employers: ICE may request to review I-9 forms and related records, but they must follow proper procedures.

‍

Vehicles and Checkpoints

Border Patrol and ICE may set up checkpoints within 100 miles of a U.S. border.

• They may ask about immigration status, but you are not required to answer.

• Agents cannot search your car without consent, probable cause, or a warrant.

• You can calmly refuse a search if they lack proper authority.

‍

Your Core Rights in ICE Encounters

• Remain silent — you do not need to answer questions about birthplace or immigration status.

• Request an attorney — you may say, “I want to speak with a lawyer before answering questions.”

• Do not open the door without a judicial warrant.

• Do not consent to searches without a proper warrant.

‍

Common Misconceptions

In my practice, I hear the same misconceptions repeated:

• Thinking that an ICE badge alone requires you to open the door.

• Believing an administrative warrant is the same as a judicial one.

• Assuming silence makes things worse. In fact, silence is a protected right.

‍

Practical Tips

• Stay calm and do not resist physically.

• Do not lie or provide false documents.

• Ask to see any warrant. Check if it is signed by a judge.

• Keep important documents and the phone number of a trusted lawyer accessible.

‍

Why This Knowledge Matters

Knowing your rights is not about avoiding the law — it is about ensuring that enforcement is carried out within the limits of the Constitution. An informed community is a safer community.

‍

Conclusion

I wrote this guide to help the public understand what ICE agents can and cannot legally do during arrests. Awareness of these rules helps families prepare and respond calmly if faced with an encounter.

If you need experienced legal guidance for your immigration case — whether family-based, employment-based, or another immigration process — contact me at SG Legal Group. My team and I will help you navigate the system with confidence. Consultations are available in English, Russian, or Romanian. Call 410-344-7100 or visit our contact page to schedule a consultation.